Criminal Justice Gangs LA City Government

Will Homeboy Really Close It’s Doors?

homeboy-at-night

I know I have been a broken record on this topic.
But I honestly cannot imagine a Los Angeles without Homeboy.

So, with a brand new AP story [below] on Homeboy’s perilous circumstances, I thought it was time to do a quick numbers comparison that I have been meaning to do for some time.

When I return from Boston I will follow-up in more detail. But here are the broad strokes of the now very immanent probability that Homeboy will have to turn out the lights on all its services—and how it’s services compare to those that the city is funding.

First of all let me explain that Homeboy would not close its businesses-–Homeboy Silkscreen, Homeboy Bakery, the Homegirl Cafe et al—-as they are self supporting.

It is those free services that would have to go: tattoo removal, job training and placement, psychological counseling, legal services, GED classes, parenting classes, case management, and more.

More than even the services, Homeboy is a safe haven. A community. A rare place where men and women may redefine themselves. This is why approximately 8000 people from all over LA County came to the Homeboy Industries offices in 2008 in the hope of getting help to turn their lives around. The flow of clients has only become greater this year.

It is these services that are teetering at the abyss.

Now the AP has a story on the issue.

*****************************************************************************************************************

BUT BEFORE THE AP STORY, HERE ARE SOME FACTS TO CONSIDER:

Despite what the AP story suggests, the promised $500,000 from Villaraigosa’s office has yet to materialize. (It is supposed to come in September.) And the fact that the mayor’s office has bought t-shirts for its own funded gang programs from Homeboy Silkscreen, while certainly a nice gesture, is neither a grant nor a donation. It is a purchase. Ditto taking staffers to lunch at Homegirl Cafe.

And about that 8000 that Homeboy served last year: In July, the Reverend Jeff Carr, the head of the mayor’s gang program, gave his progress report to the city council. At that time, Carr told the council that, in the period between January and July, his 12 contracted gang intervention agencies had referred a total of 144 people to services similar to those that Homeboy provides—“case management, job search
assistance, educational, and financial counseling.”

I’ll say that number again: 144.

Since January to July is a half year, let’s cut Homeboys client volume in half, making it 4000 people served in a like time period.

So that is 4000 versus 144.

Yet, despite the fact that it is doling out millions in gang violence reduction money elsewhere
, the city has not given its largest and most successful gang intervention agency a single penny.

Could somebody please explain the practical rationale here? I still cannot seem to grasp it.

And if someone knows of a way to see these numbers differently, please, by all means, tell me how I have it wrong.

But do it soon. Time is now running very short for Homeboy.

**************************************************************************************************************

Okay, enough lecturing from me. Here’s a chunk of the AP piece:

The Rev. Greg Boyle has walked through gunfire to quell gang violence, gotten sworn enemies to work peacefully together and redeemed hardcore criminals. But he never thought money would be the downfall of the nation’s largest anti-gang program.

After Friday, however, all bets are off at Homeboy Industries. The Roman Catholic priest’s 21-year-old effort to rehabilitate gang members by offering jobs, counseling and schooling, will run out of cash — the result of an economic recession that has ripped a $5 million hole in the nonprofit’s budget this year.

“It’s safe to say I’m losing sleep over this,” said the snowy-bearded Jesuit who won international acclaim and was chronicled in a book and documentary film. “I have 400 employees counting on me and 12,000 more who walk through our doors every year.”

In a modern building in Boyle Heights just east of downtown Los Angeles
, Boyle provides help and hope in a one-stop-shop for getting lives back together.

Under his slogan “nothing stops a bullet like a job,” he hires reformed gang members in a bakery, silk screening shop, and cafe he founded to employ and train youths who crave a second chance but who are shunned by traditional employers.

He also provides classes to equip young adults for life such as driver’s education, parenting classes and high school equivalency and to help them deal with their violent pasts underscored by criminal records, drug addiction and post-traumatic stress disorder.

For many former gang members, Homeboy Industries is like walking into a home they never had.

Rosa Crespin said she desperately wanted to change her life after serving two years in juvenile lockup for stealing cars and assault and after having a baby in May. She applied fruitlessly for about 200 jobs, until she entered Homeboy and was hired to do clerical work.

“People will always judge you by what you were,” said the 18-year-old whose arms and fingers are dotted with tattoos — the symbols of gang affiliation. “Here, people understand where you’re coming from. It gives you a shoulder to lean on that you can do it. People walk out changed.”

Boyle’s combination of compassion, practical skills and rules — employees are subject to random drug tests — has made his program a model for gang intervention across the country and abroad.

Homeboy is one of few agencies that have proven success with a population traditionally difficult to reach, said Beatriz Solis, director of healthy communities for The California Endowment, which recently gave Homeboy $500,000 for mental health programs and has donated to the nonprofit since 1999.

But this year Homeboy started to run into financial trouble — contributions from foundations and corporations dried up, government contracts were slashed in half, and state budget woes made collecting bills for past contracts impossible, including a $310,000 tab owed by the Division of Juvenile Justice for mentoring young parolees, said Mona Hobson, director of development.

The nonprofit, which carries a top, four-star ranking from nonprofit analyst Charity Navigator, has lost about 40 percent of its $9 million annual budget.

Boyle, who is fighting leukemia, has managed to push Homeboy from payroll to payroll the last few months — $350,000 every two weeks for salaries and bills. He’s gathered $200,000 through Web site donations, put Homeboy merchandise online to ramp up sales, frozen new hiring and extended cafe hours to serve dinner on weekends.

Hobson has reached out to foundations and corporations she hasn’t tapped before and that’s resulted in a trickle of contributions.

But Homeboy is now hitting a dead end.

Read the rest.

28 Comments

  • Homeboy’s might have more business if it moved out of that high crime area and started charging for those free services.

    Sincerely, I suspect that an over-emphasis on compassion with ignorance or disregard for sound business practices have resulted in the organization having to suspend its goal of helping others. What good is great compassion if it runs you out of business and renders the organization unable to provide even a modest amount of help?

    While Boyle was teaching people to fish rather than giving them fish, he couldn’t make make his own organization self-sufficient. The business plan was faulty. Only government can count on continuing to take money from people when times get tough.

    I’ve never seen the books, but I suspect that debt service on the new building was the killer. I go nuts when start-up businesses go out and buy everything new when they could get by on less expensive used equipment in order to get over the hump.

    Who is on the board and where were they?

  • Were these conductors texting when the train ran off the track?

    From the Homeboy site….

    Homeboy Board of Directors and Honorary Board

    2008 Board of Directors

    David V. Adams, Sr. President
    J. Michael Hennigan, Founding President
    J. Mario Molina, M.D., Vice President
    Carol Biondi
    H. Thomas Boyle, Treasurer
    Rosa Campos
    Alex Chaves, Sr.
    Dwight Hotchkiss
    Christine Lynch, Secretary
    Amanda Mansour
    Charlie McPhee
    Fr. Al Naucke, S.J.
    Joe Seager
    Rob Smith
    Carlos Vasquez
    Honorary Board

    Herb Alpert (??)
    Robert Graham
    Anjelica Huston
    David G. Price

    Who in that group had financial expertise?

    I’d like to see the minutes of those board meetings.

  • TrollBoy asks about financial expertise among the HomeBoy board and puts 2 question marks next to Herb Alpert’s name.

    This is another entry in the annals of TrollBoy’s stupidity and hubris (in this case the hubris of small minds.)

    Herb Alpert – founded a record company, served as chief executive, worked the business end for 30+ years and made hundreds of millions of dollars when he wasn’t playing his trumpet but signing other artists, producing and distributing records. TrollBoy does his usual drive-by here, not adding anything to the conversation and with his dummy “??” shows he has neither knowledge nor respect for anything or anyone who doesn’t fit into his very tiny “Investors Business Daily” wingnut purview…

    “I’ve never seen the books, but I suspect…” – so shut the fuck up. You’re a goddam knownothing who can’t hold your ugly tongue no matter how useless your drivel.

    Total fucking waste of anyone’s time who reads this site.

  • Celeste, Father Greg and Homeboy/Homegirl Industries is a successful intervention program that has a track record of success that goes back years. 8,000 mostly young troubled people served last year as opposed to 144 clients from 12 intervention agencies under the wing of “gang czar” Rev. Jeff Carr and the city. I think the numbers and success rate tell a story here, what’s Carr’s salary? If Carr was a roofer and only put down a fraction of the square footage he was paid to complete in a timely manner, and at the same time another roofer completed 5000 times the square footage, well the choice would be clear, get rid of the slacker and increase the salary of the go getter.

    On this subject I saw where ex LAPD Chief Bratton listed the LA gang problem as one of the most frustrating and compelling reasons he left his position as Chief.
    Continuing to put a band aid on this huge lesion will one day lead us to our death beds.

    PS, I didn’t know Father Greg had leukemia Celeste, he’ll be in my prayers and thoughts, he’s a great man.
    When it rains it pours.

  • Woody’s opening sentence was bait. Reg bit, but I guess somebody had to. That’s the essence of trolling, right? At least in the fishing sense. The “troll” under the bridge is abstract. Woody, I think maybe Greg Boyle and the outfit moving out of the very area they’re trying to focus on would be counter-productive and more like the puppet entities set up by LA’s Mayor that really doesn’t address the problem. The situation looks like trickle down recession to me. Everybody suffers. No amount of virtual carwashes will help. we’re all hurting – – except maybe the select few who maybe should get off their bootie* and kick in where it would help. NOW would be a great time.
    * asses, assets, tax deductable contributions,offshore holdings,hedge funds, mattress money, abundant trust funds, or even that extra steak dinner this week.

  • Homeboy/Homegirl Industries is a successful intervention program that has a track record of success that goes back years. 8,000 mostly young troubled people served last year

    *************

    I personally know (4) four troubled youths who were “served” by HomeBoy Industries last year. All four of them are now locked-up in juvenille hall, I would like to see the actual number of people who “really” leave the cholo lifestlye after being served by HomeBoy Industries.

    While prayer is all well and good, if more L.A. Eastside residents actually donated money or volunteered and worked for HomeBoy Industries maybe they wouldn’t be broke.

    The people who actually need to get involved to solve their gang problems are expecting some rich gavacho Lone Ranger to provide the solution to a home-grown problem. I have really bad news, the gavacho Lone ranger is NOT coming to keep your kids and familia out of gangs and jail.

    The Gavacho Lone Ranger is not coming to L.A. Eastside to tutor and educate your kids. But the gavacho may come and tear down an old varrio and gentrify the area to make some money. But keep whining on the Internet the Gavachos are laughing their asses off.

    I see Loretta Sanchez is now trying a Health Care prayer vigil.

    http://www.latinopoliticsblog.com/

  • Its been some time now that Father-G has been ill – he never talks about it and goes about his life knowing that everything is in the Lord’s hand.
    I have never seen him cry about it either….
    Its so frustrating that they want to fund a half-ass organizations like Culeros In Schools but they totally ignore an organization that its founder and president has no personal interest on profitting from any government funding or embezzlement….. total bullshit.
    I remember T. Cardenas when he was a kid in SFV and I dont understand how a guy that was such a little cry baby wennie who got punked and beaten up by everyone in the neighborhood- would allow a fat punk ass idiot like Blinky and his gangster cohorts to bullshit him and intimate him on doing whatever they want him to do – straight bitch.
    Sorry for my french – I see everyone else on here expression their views with emotions – why not me:)

  • Big Betty – Ive seen a couple of them do really well overall – but they had to move out of the area (state) permanently. I’ve seen others do good but they refuse to go see their “pappy” because they had a fall out over issues that Father G played favoritism with certain 1XFlats gang members. Ive told these guys numerous times that they have to understand that Father-G’s work started on one side of the projects. He was not his fault that enemy kids couldn’t cross over to be counseled.
    In matter of fact, I’ll be in East Los tonight talking to one of Father-Gs “ex-favorite homie” – he is working and doing very well. No arrest since like 2002. I dont see him ever buying a house but at least he supports his little son with the salary he makes. More importantly – his alive.

  • On other note, aside from trying to plant a seed in these kids, juveniles are the hardest group to help or turn around. They are at an age where they are banging with no thought of life or consequences. – Aside from respecting him, they usually dont care about some Catholic father’s help or counseling sessions. They may think he’s really cool because he knows the street language but they dont get the bigger picture or mission.
    One thing I can tell you from experience, Father-G’s does not go to their houses trying to force them to come to the program. He puts it on you to make that stepping change, that request for personal help. If you decide to miss your appointment because the gang banging or a house party was more important – thats on you.
    Ive interviewed hundreds of juveniles that have attempted to be served by Homeboy’s industry. Mentally, they are just not ready. If they are not mature enough to stop getting re-arrested and stop being involved in gang banging – what makes people think they are mature enough to participate in Homeboy’s services. However, when it comes to adults services – Ive seen a whole different outcome and result.
    Like the homies say it, “I put that on my MOM homie”.

  • Wow. That just really highlights how ineffective government agencies have become in dealing with things like gangs. That’s a very sad thing.

  • Man.I’ve seen people blog all over the internet but it seems that the poplock guy is really in tune with the city’s troubling gang issues and interworkings. Why do they even listen to people like C. Rice or Jeff Carr?

  • Then write ’em a personal check, Celeste, but for God’s sake let’s not waste any public money on what has become the biggest scam west of Madoff: taxpayer $$ given to con artists who pretend to transform thugs into upright citizens. It’s become an enormous bunko op. If these guys are legit, bless their little hearts. But is there any damn thing that can work in this country without folks putting their slinky hands into my pockets?

  • Your train of thought derailed Woody. You think you are so transcendent? Don’t scream so much. Practice peace onto others, instead of only yourself as you are accustomed (as I gather from your insular posts), and you’ll be surprised at the benefits. I don’t think that’s a discipline you seek to accomplish though.

  • Maybe this is a bit nieve of me but can’t the silkscreen, bakery and cafe help finacially support the other services Homeboy offers? It’s seems the services that Homeboy is gonna lose such as tattoo removal, job training and placement, psychological counseling, legal services, GED classes, parenting classes and case management, are the services that thses guy’s and girls really need.

  • I just want to point out that Homeboy also houses a charter hgih school serving more than 60 students. While the school could survive outside of Homeboy, the students who attend have a pretty poor track record of attending school anywhere but juvenile hall and probation camps. They have been through multiple LAUSD schools and often through other charter schools as well, but without success. What makes Homeboy different is that they come for Homeboy and Father Greg and are kind of lured into an education on the side.

    Last year, five students graduated from the school.

    As for the comment from Big Betty, it is true that some young people served at Homeboy slip back into the halls and camps. But the school at Homeboy has begun making a concerted effort to follow young people to ensure they are placed in appropriate classes and return to school when they are released. This is not a practice I have seen in LAUSD or LA charter schools. So I still think these young people have a better chance of making it with Homeboy to come back to than without it.

  • reg, you comment in #3 is total idiocy. In the posts, one can’t speculate or offer an opinion on issues, especially when the subject is within his field of expertise? You’re ridiculous.

    I think that I’ve seen enough books and worked with enough non-profits (a lot) to sense what the problems are, which is more than financial wizard Herb Alpert apparently did.

    Where is the accountability for those who were supposed to be minding the store and now are letting people down because they didn’t? Being on the board is supposed to be a deeply serious duty rather than an honor for bragging purposes.

  • “expertise” isn’t shooting your silly mouth off when you have absolutely zero facts. Of course, in your case that’s your only known expertise.

  • Expertise lets a doctor speculate fairly accurately about a disease after he’s heard the symptoms but before examining the patient. Expertise lets me associate past observations and experience with the current situation to speculate about the problem.

    This is not “shooting your sily mouth off”: I’ve never seen the books, but I suspect that debt service on the new building was the killer.

    I’ve heard the symptoms and seen pictures and read about the new building and I have an education and background on this. On the other hand, you, reg, have nothing, so don’t tell me that the building debt service hasn’t been a major factor in Homeboy’s financial problems. Also, Celeste would be quick to correct me if she knew otherwise.

    As ususal, it’s you who is shooting off his mouth with nothing when you accuse others of doing so.

    I’m offering suggestions. You offer noisy, useless distractions.

  • I have not seen first hand the current accounting books or annual reports for Homeboy’s Industry.
    I was there when they were still a very small non-profit organization running the bakery off 1st (prior to it burning down) and then the silkscreen warehouse setup on Alameda. I dont even know if Rudy is still there today…I think that was he name.
    In what I remember, most of the businesses were ran to support jobs for the homies – almost never to push the employees to bring up the profit margins. The director/owner was paid his straight salary because he/she was running the business with the philosophy that they were doing this for Father-G’s vision.
    From all media advertisment, many may think that the businesses are making whopping money – but they forget that they are all small businesses – not like Hersey or Coke a Cola. How many small businesses survive? Today’s economy is not helping either.

  • poplockerone,

    All good points. By the way, the director of the Silkscreen is Ruben Rodriguez. (You were close.) His wife Cristina is the co-director of the project, and they both are still there.

    Ruben and Cristina have given their lives to this project and are wonderful, wonderful people.

  • Sorry, its been a long time since I’ve seen them- I remember him and his wife vividly well. Really Really nice people, very humble people, with an incredible faith for their workers and a hell of patience. I wish them all the best….especially in these hard times.

  • Celeste, you’ve only whined about needing more money. Where are the people who were supposed to be managing the business, controlling costs, and making realistic forecasts and budgets? Do you know some of the board members? What have they said?

    Also, let me know how the financial advisory group, “Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass,” let this financial situation get out of hand.

Leave a Comment