COVID-19 & Justice

Op-Ed: Prisons Are Overwhelmed With COVID-19. Why Aren’t Governors Doing More?

WLA Guest
Written by WLA Guest

by Chesa Boudin and Miriam Aroni Krinsky

As the Trump administration abdicated its role in leading the fight against coronavirus, governors have emerged as critical players and sometimes media darlings — coordinating the provision of supplies, overseeing the closing and reopening of economies, and calibrating the response to the pandemic. But they have utterly failed to protect their constituents in what have emerged as the largest coronavirus hotspots — state prisons. Indeed, over half of the 84,000 coronavirus infections and 703 deaths among people incarcerated and working in local, state and federal correctional and detention facilities in the United States are in state prisons.

At a time when dense living conditions and overpopulated facilities are a ticking time bomb for spread of the virus, prisons across the U.S. have decreased their population by only 5 percent since the pandemic’s onset. Meanwhile, jails have achieved on average a 30 percent reduction in population, with some jurisdictions cutting detention rates in half or even more. That progress is attributable to many local elected prosecutors who acted swiftly with others to reduce the number of people entering jails and release as many individuals as possible. But these local leaders have limited power to impact prisons — prompting 35 district attorneys from around the country to issue an open letter and video to governors urging action. As they write, “Being confined in a prison or jail should not be a death sentence. Yet, in the context of COVID-19 that is exactly what it has become for far too many.”

The failure of governors has been universal. A recent report from the ACLU and Prison Policy Institute found gross negligence in every state, although some states have exhibited particularly egregious responses. In Michigan — where as of mid-July there have been 68 deaths and nearly 4,000 positive tests of people in state prisons — Gov. Whitmer has declined to support a ballot measure that would allow for early release of individuals incarcerated in state prisons who can be safely returned to the community. In California, Gov. Newsom recently ordered the release of 8,000 individuals, but that represents under 8 percent of an already overcrowded state prison population and a far larger number — nearly 50 percent of the population — has being classified by California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s own data as “low risk.” Moreover, this action comes too late to prevent the explosive and deadly outbreak at the overcrowded San Quentin prison and to save the lives of over 30 people behind bars who have died from COVID-19.

The brunt of the pandemic has been borne by Black and Brown communities. Abandoning the men and women who are currently behind bars — disproportionately people of color due to mass incarceration — will only amplify existing racial health disparities. The vast majority of people in prisons will come home again, if they survive this pandemic. But they will return home, often to already medically underserved communities, with potentially life-long health complications and disabilities stemming from their infection, thereby amplifying existing inequities.

How governors respond to this pandemic will define their legacy. They all face a choice: save lives in prisons now, or hand down potential death sentences with their inaction and watch harm ripple through communities and exacerbate inequities into future generations. The answer seems clear. Let’s hope our nation’s governors agree.

Chesa Boudin is the district attorney for San Francisco, California. Miriam Aroni Krinsky is a former federal prosecutor and executive director of Fair and Just Prosecution

This essay also appears in The Appeal as part of The Appeal’s collection of opinion and analysis.


  • Two liberal prosecutors, whining about convicts. Stunningly stupid. People are dying out in society; people are dying in custody. They chose their fate when they committed crimes. They should not get released early because of China Flu. I suppose they deserve (?) adequate medical care while in custody, but not a free pass to come back out and victimize more people.

    • We Have a Brand New Batch of Victims, and it can Only Get Worse. Why? There is NO Room at the Inn for the Injustice and Violence in Our Streets, Nowdays! Too Much Happening, and Criminels are given a ticket! No Jails Available. Hope You Enjoy it!

  • Mass Incarceration is a liberal lie, there is no such thing. We have way too few people in prison than need to be in prison, we see evidence of that every day in the killings that go on across our nations and the epidemic of crime we’re going through that people like Taylor and Celeste never write about or care about. The dead young across our nation, speaking of Black and Brown, at least fourteen murdered in the past few weeks you two would never think to dedicate your time to, some only one year old. This isn’t a White issue but Democratic scum politicians place the blame on them, it’s their fault that guns are on the streets.

    I wonder at times what you ladies dance cards look like. Just how many of the incarcerated, at least at one time, have you had some type of relationship with? To each their own, and I don’t expect an answer or an honest conversation, but I’ve known more than a few “good girls” that got way too infatuated by “bad boys”, and their lives became way too twisted. Seems to me with your over the top concern for hard core felons there’s probably some relationships you don’t talk about here that might explain your constant worrying about the scum in our prisons.

  • In an article published not so long ago on witness la, you reported only 35 deaths out a population of approximately 120,000 inmates in CDCR from Covid 19. The deaths in LA County Nursing Homes is over 1,500 alone. Have you no sense of proportion and integrity. Govt failure is not regarding the protection of its prison population but of its vulnerable seniors. The mischaracterization of the State of California’s situation is shameful. Truly vulnerable people are dying in nursing home and the SF District Attorney and Miriam keep spinning a misleading narrative. Hello SF recall Chesa Boudin and everybody stop donating to Miriam Krinsky’s Fair and Just Prosecution Organization. If they lie about this what else will they lie about.

  • If masks protect from the CHINA FLU then why are the prisoners catching it?

    Either witnessLa is lying or mask effectiveness is a hoax.

    Which is true?

Leave a Comment