There are now reports that the 11 hour race-based riot that broke out at around 8:30 Saturday night at the California Institute for Men—more commonly known as Chino—was not spontaneous, but pre-planned.
Prison spokesman Lt. Mark Hargrove told the Riverside Press-Enterprise that on Thursday Chino staff caught wind of plans to start a riot, so the prison was put on a modified lockdown, which included feeding inmates in their cells and not allowing any unnecessary movement of an inmate outside his cell.
That lockdown was lifted on Saturday—at which point the riot began.
By the time it was finished, 1300 of the prison’s 5,911 inmates had been involved, 250 inmates were injured, 55 of those were hospitalized, one dorm was burned to the ground and five more were rendered uninhabitable.
Yet despite the riot’s size, there were no deaths and no injury to staff. There was one serious head injury and multiple stabbings, yet by last night, 38 of those 55 who were hospitalized had been released.
The correctional officers deserve much credit for their skillful handling of the event. According to the CDCR, to eventually control the riots, officers primarily used batons, pepper spray, and “less lethal force”—projectiles and the like.
After the riot began, the nine other So Cal prisons were also put in lock down—just to be on the safe side— to prevent the riot from spreading.
As to how preplanned the riot was, my friend former CDCR warden David Winett told me that a look at the weapons gathered post-riot will tell a lot. In other words, weapons that were mostly the tools of the moment, glass shards and the like, will convey one message, a high number of pre-made items, another.
Chino was one of the California correctional institutions in which the policy of segregating prisoners by race was being gradually reversed in response to the 2005 Supreme Court decision, even though few state prison experts thought this a terribly safe idea, given the stranglehold the race-based prison gangs have on the corrections system. The desegregation of cells and dorms began slowly to roll out, institution by institution at the end of last summer.
*************************************************************************************************************
The California Institution for Men—or Chino, as it is more commonly known—is a dilapidated, 68-year-old complex that sprawls in the shadow of the San Gabriel Mountains on twenty-five hundred acres of ranch land, forty miles east of downtown Los Angeles. It was built in 1941, the third state facility for men authorized in California, eighty-one years after San Quentin’s construction in 1850, a half century after Folsom in 1881.
Alcatraz was built well before Chino, in 1861, but the near mythical island penitentiary that once housed Al Capone and Robert Stroud, the Birdman, was part of the federal system, first a military prison, then in 1934, re-outfitted as the country’s first maximum security super-prison.
Chino, by contrast, was originally intended as a minimum-security facility, also the first in the nation. It was designed to house low level offenders and short-term inmates about to be paroled. Then when determinate sentencing and a rash of stringent drug laws caused California’s prison population to inflate with extraordinary rapidity in the early 1980s, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation needed another place to stash short time but higher-risk prisoners and, unwittingly, allowed the leaders of the Aryan Brotherhood to cluster at Chino. Instead of controlling the mix in those early stages, the CDC’s over-bureaucratized system kept transferring inmates apparently without cognizance of their gang associations. Soon all the prison gangs were represented and the state’s so-called safe facility became among its most violent.
Chino became notorious for three incidents. The first was the 1983 escape of inmate Kevin Cooper within 24 hours of his arrival at the prisons. Cooper killed four people within a few days of his escape
Then in 2005, Corrections Officer Manuel Gonzalez was stabbed to death at Chino—the first such incident in 20 years. Subsequent investigations found that staff had chronically ignored basic prison security protocols.
Finally, in 2006, Correctional Officer Shayne Allyn Ziska was charged with conspiring to help members of the prison gang, the Nazi Lowriders assault and kill other inmates at Chino. (He was sentenced to 17-years, which strikes me as a bit short. But whatever.)
************************************************************************************************************
Parts of Chino function as what is called a Reception Center—meaning that it is the entry point into the system for parolees returning to custody and newly sentenced male felons from several Southern California counties. At Reception inmates receive diagnostic tests, medical and mental health screening, and other kinds of assessments in order to determine “inmates’ appropriate institutional placement.”
It is also the last stop at which many of those same inmates go to be processed out of prison and back into the non-locked up world.
It was in one of the reception centers–specifically the Reception Center West facilities—that the riot took place.
it is precisely because of the transient nature of their population,that reception centers, like jails, tend to be less socially stable (in terms of the prison gang-run hierarchical social structure that dominates all California prisons) and thus more danger prone.
It doesn’t help that Chino is so run down and in need of repair that in at least one dorm, the hot water was off for more than a year, meaning no hot showers. And a number of inmates have told me that the there are broken windows in many of the cells allowing flies, mosquitoes and other bugs to enter at will.
It also doesn’t help that the prison was designed to hold 3160 inmates, but now has more than 5,900.
Upcoming budget cuts, if not carefully chosen, could matters worse in places like Chino.
Chino and the 9 other So Cal prisons remain on lockdown until further notice.
********************************************************************************************
Photo capture from KTTV video.
C: the policy of segregating prisoners by race was being gradually reversed in response to the 2005 Supreme Court decision….
After that ruling, I and millions of others saw this gang and race conflict coming from a mile away. If the Court wants to run the prisons, then put their law clerks on the inside.
It’s just another case of courts putting political correctness over common sense and experience and in an area in which rules have to be different than on the outside.
In response to this riot and the inmate crowding, maybe the court will order the inmates released. That’s only fair. I have a good idea for the court…make it illegal for criminals to carry weapons!!
Maybe the Court could have a weapons buy-back program like Fresno’s this weekend and give inmates $50 gift cards to Target for each weapon submitted. But, the Court better get those inmates released pronto, as there’s an expiration date on the gift cards.
– – –
C: at least one dorm, the hot water was off for more than a year….
Well, there’s a reason to riot. I bet that the installation of the plush pile carpet was delayed, too.
– – –
C: designed to hold 3160 inmates, but now has more than 5,900
That doesn’t mean that it’s either crowded or overcrowded – for which there is a distinction. Either way, any crowding wasn’t the cause of the riot.
California just needs a better class of prisoners.
An interesting point brought up at LA Observed Blog.
With a major prison riot taking place just a few miles from downtown LA why was the disturbance featured on the front page of the New York Times and not hardly mentioned at the LA Times yesterday?
Was it a case of good ol boy politics? Does the LA Times have an interest in the Prison Industrial Complex? Or was it a example of being safe and too chickenshit to report the truth?
Yeah, I thought it was weird too, regarding the Times placement—or lack of placement—of the riot story. They had a story quite early. But you had to go to LA Now the blog to find it, it was not linked from the front page that I ever saw. Instead, as Oakwood alum noted, the Lily Burk funeral was the big banner. Now obviously I thought the Lily Burk story was important—in that I covered it a lot. But her memorial is not a front page story, I’m sorry.
I think this is no kind of plot but all a matter of trying to draw readers, and that their strategies are confused, desperate and ever-changing
Woody, the hot water thing is silly.
But I quite agree with you on the Supreme Court decision. Even the ultra-liberal 9th circuit said: Look, we don’t like segregation either, but we like prison rioting even less so, hey, guys, do whatever you think you need to do to keep the peace.
The more conservative-leaning Supremes reversed the 9th Circuit and wrote in their majority opinion, ““By perpetuating the notion that race matters, racial segregation of inmates may exacerbate the very patterns of violence that it is said to counteract.”
All right and good in theory. And they had a legal precedent that led them that direction. But given the practical situation on the ground in California prisons, it wasn’t a workable plan.
Celeste, the grapevine is reporting that there may be up to ten deaths that occurred during the Chino disturbance and that there is a cover up until damage control and more investigation is completed.
I hope it is just a rumor but with a conflagration of that magnitude and fierceness it would be surprising if there weren’t any fatalities.
I’ll check.
I wonder if Sheriff Joe’s Tent City has these sorts of problems. I’d bet not.
Is there anything that can be done to stop prisons from being hotbeds of criminal indoctrination, gang violence, and rape?
John. The answer is yes. But we’d have to want to actually pay for those programs. Of course, if we don’t spend the money helping those who want to spend the time inside improving themselves, etc., we’ll surely spend much more money incarcerating them the next time they come back, and prosecuting them etc. etc. But the state legislature seems math challenged.
Answer to DQ: No deaths. I feel fairly confident of this based on what I’ve been able to find out.
John: Is there anything that can be done…?
Yes, there is a “weapons for poetry books” program.
I talked earlier to a friend of mine who works there, said he was not aware of any deaths or anyone near death but he’s not at the top of the command structure. I would consider the source as being accurate, think what you want.
Here’s the latest I’ve seen on line which seems to cover all the bases and falls in line with what I was told. By the way Celeste, the U.S.A.O. was asking for 20 years for Ziska, no way he was going to get more regardless of his exposure, no past record and a history of community involvement. He pretty much lucked out when he got Terry hatter as the judge, he’s known as being just a bit on the lenient side.
Black-Latino tensions blamed in Chino prison riot [updated]
11:18 AM | August 10, 2009
State officials said today that a riot that left scores injured and a dormitory burned at a Chino prison was the result of racial tensions between black and Latinos prisoners and announced that 1,100 inmates were being moved to other facilities.
Terry Thornton, a spokeswoman for the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, said that officials are still trying to determine exactly what sparked the violence, which damaged a unit that holds 1,300 inmates, but that race was clearly a factor.
“It was a very violent incident,†Thornton said. “We’re still trying to figure out why.â€
Following a 2005 Supreme Court decision that found routine racial segregation to be illegal, Chino and other California prisons are moving away from the historic practice of separating inmates by race. Inmates may now share cells with prisoners of different races. The barracks involved in the rioting had been fully integrated.
[Updated at 1:40 p.m.: But it remains unclear what role, if any, the Supreme Court decision played in the Chino problem. Thornton said the court ruling only applied to prisoners in cells. The violence in Chino broke out in an area where prisoners are housed in baracks, which she said was not covered by the decision. Only two prisons with cells have been integrated since the 2005 ruling, and Chino is not among them, she said.]
Thornton said the 1,100 inmates were either waiting to be transferred or en route to one of four institutions: the Calipatria State Prison in Imperial County, the California Rehabilitation Center in Norco, the Correctional Training Facility in Soledad and the Heman G. Stark Youth Correctional Facility in Chino.
Thirty inmates with non-life-threatening injuries were still hospitalized this morning.
The incident occurred in a reception center with barrack-style bunks built in the 1940s, said Curt Hagman, a California assemblyman whose district includes a portion of Chino. “It’s a design and facility issue more than overcrowding,†he said. “By nature prisons are violent.â€
The California prison system canceled visiting hours over the weekend and is in lockdown indefinitely, Thornton said.
— Nicole Santa Cruz
Okay, that’s two sources that say no deaths.
Interesting about Ziska, Sure Fire.
About the Surpremes decision. I’ll revisit that in a while. Turns out all the reporting on it—my own included—drew exactly the wrong conclusion.
Those sources were told to keep quiet if they wanted to live.
C: The more conservative-leaning Supremes reversed the 9th Circuit
Really?
GARRISON S. JOHNSON, PETITIONER v. CALIFORNIA et al.
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
No. 03—636
5-3 opinion
The Majority:
Stevens – Liberal
Ginsburg – Liberal
Souter – Liberal
Breyer – Liberal
O’Connor – Swing (Shifted to the left)
Kennedy – Swing (Supported activist court)
The Minority:
Scalia – Conservative
Thomas – Conservative
Unable to Participate
Rehnquist (Cancer)
For: 4 liberals + 2 swing justices
Against: 2 Conservatives
– – –
Read this:
Daily Journal – The Defiant Ones
Aren’t smug liberals disgusting?
Waaaaay too many words..
One has to wonder how much factual info will emerge from this riot. Staff will analyze the “quality” of the weaponry, informants will divulge their skewed views, and the result will be 1100 inmates dispersed to other institutions to regroup and incite new violence in their new joints. I saw CTF-Central on full boil and its not a place anyone wants to be. No Woody, it aint Woodstock.
Ha Ha. Woody says he saw this racial violence coming from a mile away when the desegregation began in 2005. Hey, nobody tell him that racial violence in California prisons and jails started a half century ago, and that the racial gang violence in LA as we know it started in the ’90s. Let’s let him keep walking around with the toilet paper stuck to his shoe.
Yeh, Woody. You saw this from a mile away when they desegregated the jails. Good call, man!
Sure Fire, no problem. I’ll take your word for it. You’ve only lied twice in the past two days. Humongous lies, at that, about prisons and drug sentences. Now here we are talking about prison riots, and you’ve got a source for us. OK. Sure.
I am sure the draconian Prison Industrial Complex and the Robber Barons and the powers that be are all involved in a major cover-up, I know of many latinos who have disappeared in prison. I have talked to many veteranos who would not lie about this. The L.A. Times is being silenced by the rich white “facists” who are killing innocent latinos in prison. The white prison guards started the riot and killed many innocent prisoners, it’s the old divide and conquer being used by the gavachos again.
Where do you come up with such stupidity Rob? Are you truly as dense as you seem? I worked tactical teams and gang units in the 90’s, we had few responses to gang related crimes that were black on brown or vice versa. the vast majority was same race squabbles as the Hispanics hadn’t moved as far into the black communities as they have in the last 10 years.
You’ve been smoking that easy enough to make crack apparently. What background if any in this area do you have, sounds like none, just another internet troll.
Don’s hitting the pipe long and hard as well.
California Institute for Men was the Model of Rehabilitation now it is the result of public hysteria over crime.
Sure Fire – I have extensive backgroung… in trolling streetgangs.com, IntheHat, brownpride.com, streethassle.com, and numerous other websites not to mention I am a connoisser of fine gang movies such as American Me, Duke of Earl, Blvd Nights, Mi Vida Loca, Blood In Blood Out, Colors and such. For your information I am a self proclaimed expert on gangs.
Does anyone know for sure which “two prisons with cells” have been integrated?
I dont believe there were any deaths but the fire and destruction was visible from the street. I do believe men in prison should have to be intergrated. Men are being intergrated into the white supremacist gangs, black gangs, asian gangs and other terrorist groups like alcata. They need to intergrate with society when they get out. Why should they be able to carry on with their gangbang ways in prison? Why should we promote the segregation of peoples in prison I say they deserve solitary confinement if they have killed someone, or learn to get along with others and mix them up. I have to pass by there everyday and put my son in a school very close. Homes and schools are being built on land which was once supposed to insulate the prison from society. It is very frightening to me to take a child to the park right next door and hear the sirens going off. Most parents dont even know what is going on there. The OVERCROWDING, you use to be able to see on the internet how they have bunk beds in the mess hall where the eat.Now we have the College building there. Men should have to get their education and work while they are in.I dont think they should be able to hang around and socialize with there gumbas. My husband works all the time. These men should be taught and be educated and made to pick a career, instead of letting them out to the lives of crime and gangs they normally live!!! That is the sad part of illegals comming into the country. They cant make a decent living so they resort to illegal ways of making a living. I am resident of Chino 25 years and follow the news closely Dont I deserve freedom to live in a safe area. Gangs have ruined LA and other major cities. I know they have been around since the beginning of the US like in NY.Gangs form from different people ganging up with their own kind and promoting hate of others. Why do they hate so much??
[…] regarding integrating California’s prisons—and the race-based riot at Chino. (See my earlier post for back […]